Close
Contact us
Close

8th April 2021

Due Diligence: don’t make the easy things hard

Share this page:

Advances in automated approaches to strategic patent intelligence pave the way for increased efficiency and reduced transaction costs.

Due diligence is the essential requirement in a transaction to establish ‘what’s going on’. It is about identifying risks that might otherwise trip-up a purchaser on the foundational principle of let the buyer beware. Patents have always been an important aspect of this and more so today than ever before.

What’s involved in patent due diligence?

In an M&A context, patent due diligence is the need to establish that the business being bought or sold has all the rights necessary to carry on. This requires at a minimum:

  • Reliable scheduling of patents in a form that can be rapidly reviewed,
  • Estimating costs for managing the portfolio and how it fits with your existing portfolio,
  • A picture of how the target asset compare with other owners of similar patented technologies,
  • An understanding of how existing patent licences bolster or weaken the commercial position,
  • Whether there is significant litigation risk, either now or in the foreseeable future.

What’s the problem?

The problem has always been that due diligence is slow and expensive. Too much time reviewing documents and not enough time to identify and resolve issue that arise. Let’s consider this challenge in the context of a typical transaction:

  • Patents owned – a typical portfolio for a business with more than $1B of revenue is 250 patent families – each with say 3 grants or applications across a range of international patent offices (countries). The minimum information required for each patent is description, age and status.
  • Licensed patents – the patent licences need to be categorised as “in” (granted to the business) or “out” (granted by the business). These are complex agreements and due diligence means conducting a detailed review. Material terms include not only the patents, the scope of the licence (eg: exclusive/non-exclusive), term and financials (in particular royalty payments). You can reasonably expect there to be 20 or more agreements of this sort.
  • Used, but not owned or licensed – this is commonly referred to as third party infringement risk. Some of this will be known (actual or threatened litigation) but most of this risk falls into Rumsfeld’s “unknown unknowns”.

It’s easy to see why conventional manual review might be slow and expensive. Let’s assume that you outsource this task to external advisers charging $250ph. If we further assume that it takes an hour to review a patent and 3 hours to review a licence, that’s $80,000 before you are in any position to actually do anything. In terms of time, that’s over 300 hours, equivalent to 4 FTE weeks. This back of envelope calculation ignores infringement risk, which is often sidestepped as being too hard.

Further reading and our report

Nigel Swycher, Cipher CEO,  goes on to explore alternative approaches to this manual review and  provides an overview of where an efficient approach to due diligence is beneficial,

Efficient due diligence paves the way to real risk mitigation and gives you the opportunity to contribute to any commercial transaction with strategic insights.

Follow our four-step process and reap the rewards of taking an efficient approach to due diligence.

Due diligence: Do more for less

 

Insights & Events

The contribution of patents to enterprise value

Describing a new valuation methodology for calculating the contribution that an entire portfolio makes to the overall value of a company.
Read more

Cipher helps launch patent industry DEI initiative

Cipher has recorded a podcast with the founders of a new movement aiming to improve diversity amongst patent professionals.
Read more

Automotive Lidar technology is rapidly changing

Global Prior Art, using Cipher classified patent data has found new trends in the rapidly-evolving lidar innovation field.
Read more

The Circular Economy: Sustainable Packaging

Our report shows a step-change in industry approaches to sustainable packaging adoption across fast-moving consumer goods (FMCGs). We analysed bioplastics patent data to track which major chemical players are behind this trend.
Read more

Cipher patent analysis helps inform Mintel Sustainability Barometer

The Cipher platform was instrumental in providing data to support consumer trends giant Mintel in producing their Sustainability Barometer for 2022.
Read more

Life Sciences top patent publishing list

Life Sciences is a clear leader out of all of the patent categories tracked to chart the pace of innovation. This was one of the lead findings in Cipher’s recent global report.
Read more

With Cipher you can…

Portfolio Optimisation connecting cogs

Optimise your portfolio

Ensure you have the right portfolio to meet your strategic patenting objectives.

Read more
Competitive Intelligence

Gather competitor intelligence

Understand who’s doing what by automating patent to technology mapping.

Read more
Cross Licensing

Model cross licensing

Combine patent and revenue data to determine rational licensing outcomes.

Read more

Manage your budget

Justify patent budgets and communicate the impact of your investment.

Read more

Conduct due diligence

Automate manual reviews for efficient execution of M&A and licensing transactions.

Read more

Tackle inbound patent assertion

Be prepared with evidence to create a fast and effective threat assessment.

Read more

Benchmark your portfolio

Assess your portfolio in comparison to other owners through your technology lens.

Read more

Monetise your portfolio

Identify opportunities to create value through licensing or sale of patent assets.

Read more
Technology Trends icon

Predict technology trends

Track new technologies and discover the unknown owners of future innovation.

Read more
Icon of a meter

Create Risk Mitigation Strategies

Understand the materiality of your threats to define your risk mitigation strategy.

Read more

Improve your patent strategy now

Speak to the Cipher team today.

Review Your Portfolio